Stock Market: Why There Is Now A Second Wall Of Worry (USO, VGK, SPY, SSO, SDS)
Sy Harding: It’s an old market maxim that the stock market often climbs a wall of worry. In the current rally the S&P 500 (NYSEARCA:SPY) has gained 29% since its October low, and the wall of worry it climbed has been impressive. Reports in October showed the economic slowdown in the first half of the year worsened in July and August even as the 2nd half got underway. By November the eurozone debt crisis and fears of a potential default by Greece, and an ugly aftermath, were dominating headlines.
The market had a great time scrambling up that wall of worry.
In the last month or two those worries have gone away. However, to the extent that the market needs one, the good news is that the overall wall of worry remains in place. Some of its bricks have merely been replaced with others.
Worries about the slowing U.S. economy and eurozone debt crisis have been removed, but have been replaced by slowing economies in Europe (NYSEARCA:VGK) and Asia, rising oil prices (NYSEARCA:USO) (a situation that in the past has often snuffed out economic recoveries and bull markets), and there are even potential early signs of rising inflation, which ‘big picture’ theorists have been expecting for three years, as a result of the easy money policies used by global central banks to pull global economies out of the Great Recession.
So there is no problem with that wall of fundamental economic worries. It’s still there if the market needs it. A few bricks have been changed out, others swapped in. But it remains intact.
Another load of bricks for that wall may even be rumbling down the road, in the form of 1st quarter earnings reports.
Corporate earnings have been a wonder to behold in recent years. The driving force was relentless cost-cutting during and after the ‘great recession’ to bring costs in line with plunging sales and anemic demand. Plants were closed, millions of workers were let go. Remaining employees worked harder to keep up. So productivity picked up significantly. Lower costs and higher productivity resulted in sharply rising earnings in spite of the anemic economic recovery.
That virtuous cycle is coming to an end. There are only so many areas where costs can be cut, and those have been quite thoroughly exploited. And now payroll costs are rising again and productivity is softening. The former can be seen in the impressive big jump in employment over the last four months, while recent reports indicate productivity is slowing toward normal.
Rising payroll costs and softening productivity means it costs more to produce products. The question then becomes have companies been able to raise their prices enough in this still anemic recovery to offset those rising costs, or will earnings suffer.
We should know in a few weeks as first quarter earnings begin to be reported, and possibly sooner since corporations usually issue warnings and lower guidelines if they expect to miss forecasts, giving Wall Street firms time to lower their estimates so even disappointing earnings will still ‘beat the forecasts’.
So there are more than enough bricks to keep that wall of fundamental worries intact. And markets repeatedly demonstrate they can climb that kind of wall.
However, a real problem for the market may be developing in the form of a different wall of worry that has been building for market technicians, and unfortunately just as April approaches and the market nears the end of its traditional favorable season (as in Sell in May and Go Away).
Its bricks include overbought conditions, and a high level of bullish (NYSEARCA:SSO) and confident investor sentiment (often associated with market tops), and unusually high levels of selling (NYSEARCA:SDS) by usually savvy corporate insiders (who were buying heavily in November).
A point to consider is that this wall of technical worries may be telling us more about corporate earnings than the wall of fundamental worries, and it is earnings that ultimately drive the market.
That point is, which group is looking ahead, probably knowing more about what their companies will be reporting for 1st quarter earnings, and which group may be merely looking out the rear window, excited to see what has been happening with the market since October.
Sy Harding is editor of the Street Smart Report, and the free market blog, www.streetsmartpost.com. The Street Smart Report Online includes research and analysis on the economy and markets, and provides charts and buy and sell signals on the major market indexes, sectors, bonds, gold, individual stocks and etf’s, including short-sales and ‘inverse’ etf’s. It provides two model portfolios as guides. One is based on our Seasonal Timing Strategy, one on our Market-Timing Strategy.