ETFs Aren’t The Best Choice For All Investors Or Investments

Share This Article
November 13, 2012 1:44pm ETF BASIC NEWS

Christian Magoon: ETFs are increasingly becoming a portion of investor’s portfolios due to their efficiency, transparency and flexibility. However ETFs are not for everyone nor are they best investment vehicle in every case. So in that spirit, here’s an annotated list

of investors who may want to stay away from ETFs.

1. Most Fans Of Active Management — Despite the recent advances in active ETFs from the likes of PIMCO, AdvisorShares and Northern Trust, the active ETF space is still not robust. Most investors will be challenged to find a selection of active ETFs to choose from in a variety of asset classes. The good news however is that more active ETFs are coming and their efficient and transparent approach should offer a compelling value proposition.

2. Arm Chair Quarterbacks — Sometimes the lack of daily transparency offered by mutual funds is a blessing in disguise. Most ETFs disclose their portfolios daily which on balance allows investors better information to make decisions with. However some investors are better served only knowing their portfolio holdings once a quarter, the requirement for mutual funds. This controlled access prevents investors from being as subject to the emotion of the markets. So if you are a daily portfolio watcher with an itchy trigger finger, ETFs may not be for you.

3. Premium Shoppers — There are always consumers and investors that are not fazed by costs. By and large ETFs are like the Costco of investing. They provide access to some of the most compelling opportunities in the marketplace but at a warehouse price. Mutual funds however are similar to the Department store model which seems to attract those less price sensitive. Thus mutual funds offer a premium experience when it comes to fees. Unfortunately that premium experience is not often mirrored in the performance of mutual funds.

4. Max Taxers — This group of investors is either not concerned about taxes or believes paying the maximum amount of taxes is patriotic. We have heard this last sentiment about taxes a lot during the Presidential election cycle. The problem for investors in this “max tax” camp is that ETFs operate in a structure that is tax advantaged. Thus an ETF is a poor investment vehicle for this group. Instead traditional mutual funds make more sense.

As mentioned above, ETFs are not for every investor nor are they the perfect investment. The four groups of investors above would fare best avoiding ETFs going forward given their unique views and needs.

Written By Christian Magoon From Magoon Capital

Christian Magoon is Publisher of and He is also CEO of Magoon Capital, a strategic consultant firm to asset managers. Christian Magoon is an ETF insider, having launched over 40 ETFs in the United States to date. A widely recognized thought leader on finance and market issues, Christian regularly contributes to many financial media outlets. Prior to forming Magoon Capital in 2010, Christian was President of Claymore Securities (now Guggenheim Investments), where he built one of the fastest growing and most innovative ETF businesses in the country, gathering more than $3 billion in AUM in three years. He launched more than 40 ETFs, introducing many “firsts” to the U.S. market, including the first Frontier Markets, Sector Rotation, Solar Energy, Timber, BRIC and suite of China focused ETFs. Christian consistently provides his industry insights and knowledge as a commentator in the U.S. media speaking publicly on macro investment issues and ETF related topics. Follow him on Twitter @ChristianMagoon. In 2008, he was named by Institutional Investor News as one of the five people to watch in the U.S. ETF marketplace. In 2011,Financial Planning magazine dubbed Christian an “ETF Pioneer.”

Read Next

Get Free Updates

Join over 50,000 investors who get the latest news from!

Most Popular

From Our Partners

Explore More from

Free Daily Newsletter

Get daily ETF insights from our market experts. Never miss another important market development again! respects your privacy.

Best ETFs

We've rated and ranked nearly 2,000 ETFs and ETNs using our proprietary SMART Grade system.

View Top Rated ETFs

Best Categories

We've ranked dozens of ETF categories based on relative performance.

Best ETF Categories