BlackBerry Ltd (BBRY): Game On…Shareholder Fight Ahead

Share This Article
September 24, 2013 12:09am NYSE:IGN

buyers and sellersBillionaires Portfolio: On Monday BlackBerry Ltd’s (NASDAQ:BBRY) biggest shareholder, Fairfax Financial, announced a bid of $9 a share to take the company private. This is not the end of the Blackberry saga, it’s likely just the beginning.

Of course, the investor behind Fairfax is billionaire Prem Watsa. Watsa’s Fairfax owns around 10% of BBRY at much higher prices, roughly $17 per share.

With an official bid now on the table, and a November 4 deadline, Watsa’s bid creates a virtually risk-free trade for other influential investors to enter the trade. By stepping in today, an activist investor or group would have a floor in Watsa’s bid, and the power to influence shareholders to fight for a higher price for their shares.

Moreover, we have 42 days to see if another buyer, with a better bid, will come to the table. In Blackberry, we have the real opportunity for a bidding war. An activist investor that enters Blackberry may find himself owning shares in a company with an implicit floor, while composing a bidding war.

This is precisely the vision we laid out for our clients at last week – and in an open letter to few esteemed shareholder activists (here).

Are there challenges associated with Canada’s takeover laws. Yes. Will that mean one of the world’s best technology providers in the cell phone/mobile computing space quietly goes away for half of its book value? Unlikely.

Back in 2011, there was a company by the name of America Online.  AOL too was considered a rapidly dying business. It was hated by and poorly understood by analysts.  But it had a fantastic balance sheet, and valuable patents and technologies. Starboard Value stepped in and acquired a huge position in AOL.  They forced the company to sell its valuable patents and technology. In doing this they created instant value for the shareholders. AOL’s stock price went from a low of $10 in August of 2011 to over $40 in April of 2013.

Blackberry is a stock with about $5 in cash per share with zero debt. The company, according to a consensus of analysts has anywhere from $8 to $10 worth of patents and technology. Regardless of the synergistic value creation that those patents and technology could mean for another big mobile player (Apple, Samsung, Microsoft …) Blackberry is still selling for a substantial discount to its break-up value.

We may see three potential outcomes for Blackberry, with the involvement of an activist investor entering this situation:

Scenario 1 – Mr. Watsa has supplied a floor from which an activist investor can negotiate from on behalf of shareholders. The result: Virtually no risk and a potential premium to Watsa’s bid won for shareholders.

Scenario 2 – With an approaching November deadline and a bid on the table from Watsa, a rapidly evolving bidding war could ensue for the coveted Blackberry technology.

Scenario 3 – An activist investor could block Watsa, force the sale of Blackberry’s most valuable assets, and then force management to pay out a one-time special dividend to its shareholders.

Bottom line: With a takeover bid in place, Blackberry offers a very attractive asymmetric risk/return profile. The stock is just in need of at least one influential investor to fight for the highest value for shareholders in a Blackberry sale.

Consider this:  Comparing a Blackberry outcome to the AOL outcome (where Starboard Value forced the company to sell patents and change its strategy), Blackberry could be worth anywhere from $21 to $25 a share.

Another interesting comparable: Dell

According to Bloomberg, when Dell was taken private by Michael Dell and Silver Lake Partners, at under 6 times its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) for the prior 12 months. The valuation ranked as the lowest multiple ever paid in a buyout of a technology company for more than $1 billion.

At $9 per share, Blackberry would be valued at just 1.3 EBITDA – a quarter of the cheapest takeover in the history a billion dollar+ tech takeovers.

Disclosure:  Clients of, own shares of BBRY.  William Meade is co-founder of

william meadeWritten By William Meade From The Billionaires Portfolio

William Meade is the President of Pure Alpha Research, a hedge fund consulting and investment research firm. He is the former Director of Research at Zacks Investment Research in Chicago. Before that, he was the lead analyst at a top performing $1.2 Billion dollar institutional investment firm and hedge fund. Mr. Meade has a Masters in Applied Economics from The Johns Hopkins University. Learn more about William Meade and how he follows Billionaire Investors into stocks by visiting the Billionaires Portfolio.

9 "BUY THE DIP" Growth Stocks For 2020

Read Next

Free Investing Ideas Newsletter!

Join over 70,000 investors who get the latest insights and top rated picks from our free investment newsletter.

Most Popular

7 Safe Haven Dividend Stocks for Turbulent Times

Explore More from

Free Investment Newsletter

Join over 70,000 investors who get the latest insights and top rated picks from our free investment newsletter. respects your privacy.

Best ETFs

We've rated and ranked nearly 2,000 ETFs and ETNs using our proprietary SMART Grade system.

View Top Rated ETFs

Best Categories

We've ranked dozens of ETF categories based on relative performance.

Best ETF Categories